Replies to post #15368 on VHGI Holdings Inc fka VHGI

[MoneyStocker1]

Maybe these guys can value a coal producer...

http://www.vhgiholdings.com/index_htm_files/JANUARY_2013_VALUATION_UPDATE.PDF

Or maybe equip assets?

http://www.vhgiholdings.com/index_htm_files/Stout%20Appraisal%2092412.pdf

But Im sure you will say these guys are wrong to...your the EXPERT!

VHGI could spike soon, but it won't be because of fundamentals or profits.

That quote is pure crap!

But hey your the genius!

(facepalm)

VHGI

MS

[artisang]

EDMGUY: I used the proven reserves/o.s. because I thought you were basing your calculations on something more than proven reserves and current sales. Certainly, o/s must be a factor in determining the value of any stock. But I get your point. Is the market basing the value of these well-established coal producers on current sales and reserves alone? The market is a futures game ... look at Apple. Yes, partly driven by lemmings and emotion but also by growth potential. We would need to at least do an ROIC comparison of each (which I have not done).

[proftstocksny2]

You still have a 2/3 position. What are you holding in anticipation for? Financing? KCSA push to investors?

I am long for those and other reasons.