roguedolphin, Lukoil's offerring price to NLG is fair based on NLG's oil reserve and earning in my opinion, though seems unfair based on its trading price before acquizition announcement. Many investors judge the stock's fair price based on its trading price instead of its foundamentals. The cool reality is the stock price is never efficient.
Based on Lukoil's offerring price to NLG, PKZ should worth over $80 per share when include its refining subsidiary, and CHAR should worth at least $10 per share.
Investors cheer PKZ deal as the deal price was higher than trading price before announcement, whereas ivnestors scorn NLG deal as the deal price was lower than trading price before annoucnement. Based on fundamentals, the opposite should be true.