Replies to post #13159 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[XV19]

Don't forget David Hasselhoff :)

Nonetheless..it's SUPPOSED to be a talent contest, not a popularity one. I really think you'll see some big changes next year.

and really..short of Carrie, Kelly and maybe one other..most of the people that win A.I. end up in obscurity. Fantasia is bankrupt..her albums tanked. Ruben is nowhere to be found. The grey haired dude is off-off-off Broadway somewhere. Daughtry is kicking ass and taking names.

I think the show has run its course, jumped the shark, and is just tired. I'm looking forward to seeing what Simon's new show is like.