The Top 5 I'm Buying....
... idea is doomed to fail IMO. Just think about it. We buy different things every single day. Every one of us do. Don't we already HAVE that? It's called "posts". Everyday, we mention if we buy something we like. There is no hope, IMO, that any coordinated, organized methodology exists for creating and compiling and keeping up with some "buy 5" scenario.
Nobody is buying 5 stocks at any given moment. At least not very many people and I speculate nobody on this board. HWeb, with as many as he owns, and recognizing that he buys a single stock multiple times and holds for shorter periods, MIGHT be the exception.
What might be better would be for us to post 5 stocks at any given moment that we WOULD buy and the price we would buy them at. I'm sure we are all watching stocks and have actual or mental buy prices. But, even that, I doubt will ever get off the ground - or be sustainable if it did.
I'm not saying the top 10 that we hold is all that great either - for the reasons others have mentioned. But, if you hold a stock, it does mean something. And, we all hold stocks at any given moment and those can/do represent what we (as a group) are invested in.
Anyway, whatever the board decides is fine by me. I'm just predicting right now that any "buy 5" will never be sustainable. Of course, that is just my opinion.
Len