Replies to post #18228 on Medinah Minerals (MDMN)

[ShootinBlanks]

Well I am looking forward to an update from the company or you in the very near future. Have a nice evening!

[Getinin]

Hmmm... what to make of this??

It would seem to be honest frustrated, and final stand action that will call the rumor makers to the carpet if something doesn't happen soon...

I believe many people really do believe in this company, and are misled. Perhaps this will be the evidence - Wikileaks style - of who is to blame for all of the misleading information???

People will either get rich - or be exposed to the lies.

First problem I see, is that people are using Les Price as a source...

This should be entertaining either way.

[mrPiNK]

That post basically confirms they still don't have a deal

i.e, "Three weeks ago tomorrow night I spoke by phone with Juan Jose Quiano in Santiago. He told me several things that I did not know and have not shared publicly with anyone .... I would suggest to management that they all get off their butts and get this done"

[Done Deal]

Thank you Bill!! Andy

[tvk]

Thank you Bill. Your work is greatly appreciated. You have given them ample opportunity to do the right thing, and have gone above and beyond in giving them yet another week to do the right thing.

It just doesn't seem like that hard of a thing to communicate with your shareholders in a way that doesn't violate any reasonable/standard NDA agreement.

GLTA

[TraderRich]

wmo...

As a fellow investor with significant positions in both Cerro and Medinah, I am recommending you reconsider your intentions here.

First of all, if something was shared with you in confidentiality and you post it publicly when you were asked not to, then I strongly suspect that you are burning a bridge that I wouldn't think you would want to be burning.

Secondly, if you have such a large position in the company, and if you trust the information that was given to you and you do, in fact, believe that we are very close to a deal, then why would you not trust the source of your information to release it to the public when it is appropriate to do so? How do you know that there isn't a very good reason for why the information hasn't yet been made public?

I don't think I know of or have seen one investor in either Cerro or Medinah who is not frustrated with the slowness of things with these companies. I have posted time and time again in various ways that if you believe in what is going on here then it is logical to trust the people that you have invested so much money in to make the right decisions and move forward when it is appropriate to do so.

I have heard, but am not certain, that we were close to a deal in the past with another company when some insider shared some sensitive information with someone they shouldn't have. That person made the information public and caused the company to pull out and the deal to fold. Are you sure you want to put yourself in a situation where you could be responsible for a similar scenario happening again? I sure wouldn't want to be.

I appreciate your desire to have things out in the open and to have the companies move this process along. I'm sure that you mean well. Unfortunately, sometimes the best intentions can do the worst harm, and I believe that is a possibility here. I would hate to think about how some of the people I have seen posting here over the years would react toward anyone who somehow managed to delay or screw up the progress of these companies...

Finally, in the event that you still feel inclined to follow through with the intended actions in your post, I BELIEVE that, whether the information is true and did come from the source you have stated, it cannot be construed as fact but only hearsay/rumor unless you have some form of documented evidence supporting your claims. I am not a legal person so I do not know exactly what the law states, but as far as me personally, I am very careful not to take anything posted by anyone on these boards as factual without finding supporting evidence on my own from a primary source whenever possible. Otherwise it's all just rumor to me.

Hopefully we are in fact close to a deal and the company is able to inform the public promptly. If not, as always, I choose to trust that they are making the right decisions since not one of us knows everything that is going on behind the scenes.

Rich