Replies to post #15445 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[SSKILLZ1]

My Take on the show Tonight

This was judges pick night.

1) Zachariah- Sings another huge rock song. I didn't love this performance. When he was not powering up, his voice kind of sounded nasally. Hit the power notes fine though. Far from his best, just slightly above average for me overall. Grade C+

2) Haven- Boring and not a great song choice for her. A very off, pitchey and weak vocal. Way below average. Grade D+

3) Wei Ani- Another one of my favorite many songs. Sings a classic WH song. Another excellent vocal, she can flat out sing it doesn't really matter what song she sing, it always varies from very good to excellent. She had excellent power, even better control, and then hits the falsettos at the end. This was excellent for me. Grade A

4) Oliver- This is one boring song to say the least. Average to slightly above average vocal. But overall just Average at best for me, because I was bored listening to it. Grade C

5) Warren- I thought it was a good song choice, and he did a very good job on the performance and the vocal. Grade B+

6) IAM- Sing a classic LA song, which I thought was a good song choice for him. Although I did find it a bit boring though, but the vocal was decent. Grade B-

7) Mary Beth- Wasn't the perfect vocal, actually an average vocal, as there were a number of imperfections. But she did make me feel something so that is a plus. So I would say overall that played it up a bit for me, so I went with above average. Grade C+

8) Tyson- Sings another one of my many favorite songs with the LC hit. More emotional than normal, and he sang it very well (Although pales to the original, on vocals and emotions). A strong good performance, and one of his better performances overall so far. Grade B

9) Megan- Sings a VG hit. I continue to say I'm not her biggest fan of her tone. But it worked way better on this song than most. I thought the performance was pretty emotional, and way better than normal. Having said that her tone will only allow me to score her so high. Though it was decent. Grade B-

10) Collin- I thought it was a decent and a little out of the box song choice for him, I thought it was a strong vocal, and a good performance. I liked it. Grade B

I would of Cut: Haven,oliver, and Megan

Who they cut Tyson, Mary Beth and Oliver.

Than the judges with a twist save one of the contestants. if I were them I would of saved tyson out of the three, but they saved Oliver which admittingly would of been my last choice out of the 3. So Mary Beth and Tyson go home leaving us with 8. All is just my opinion of course.