100%. The premise that somehow the company did not tell the truth about stats - especially given the statistician hiring - does not hold water. While I know people love the "both sides" thing, there is only one credible side to this argument.
I've seen too many disasters happen in my life when people started off a sentence saying "there's no way that could happen because..."
Has the guy even seen the data yet? Do you guys personally know him, and if so, is his character infallible? How much money would he stand to make if AVXL gets AD approved?