My only question to you is how will you break the news (will you break the news?) if they end up being wrong?
Could be a tricky conversation. Or you could be good enough friends you can roast them for being wrong. I hope you'll report back if that ends up being the outcome.
The legal professionals that I deal with on a regular basis (Ones that really and truly exist, with decades of experience, that I have personal relationships with) are giving Team Sharp the nod here (overwhelmingly).