That is PRECISELY what we should be avoiding (confirmation bias) -- we should be taking the Socratic approach to the whole exercise.
I want to try on every negative angle on this thing as soon as I possibly can. Confidence should be built on careful rejection of counterarguments -- not on cheerleading.
Bouf, following your train of thought how much do you think the company is worth if we lose the appeal? Does anyone think JT would sell for $4-6 billion, or just struggle along GIA style while the stock languishes at $3-$4 a share?