Someone has indicated it is peer reviewed and highly regarded journal. Please check. Also check the Journals impact factor, a measure of its significance. You might also check how many times the article was cited and downloaded between when it was published and the patent approved.
jomama9231: Doc, are you sending this? Please confirm.i have been sending many of the comments and opinions along since last week. If you have or will be then I will refrain from doing so. By the way, well written.
One minor suggestion is on one sentence in the front: — Judge Du makes a fact error because the above statement is entirely incorrect — Can I suggest to add something like “and actually it is exactly contrary to Authors conclusion”.
Another suggestion, I don’t quite get the second error you said Du made. Maybe just me.
Since I have not read all of the briefs and am not a doctor, I'm awed by your due diligence. it reads fine to me and should probably be forwarded. I don't see how it could hurt our position and I'd like to know atty's covered every angle.