Replies to post #200801 on Amarin Corp Plc (AMRN)

[MedResCollab]

Should everything they ever say about a healthcare play be counted as wrong because they made many "wrong" calls before? -MRC

Of course not, but if their track record in being correct was 0% (Giardino), then they absolutely should not be taken seriously. -rafunrafun

I'm sorry, what are basing the above on? You are making quite a few leaps of logic here.

1) you conclude Steven Giardino = a poster that said REDUCE-IT was extremely likely to fail, based on lack of evidence of effect of EPA (this poster gave no weight to the potential for MO to have inhibited cardiac medications, apparently)

2) MRC = the same Steven Giardino as above, and only the Steven Giardino above (you conclude no one else involved with MRC or assisted in their analysis on Amarin Corp. in any way)

3) the Steven Giardino above never made a correct stock trade call in his life.

My goodness. Any evidence? It would take quite a mountain of it to prove these very concrete assertions of yours.

Kind Regards,
-MRC Team