Replies to post #15249 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[gail]

Super review! I like how you did that and i agree that its dumb you get told first if you go through or not then you still sing.

[ONEBGG]

Really good review, I see we agree on the most likely group of possible winners at this point.

[SSKILLZ1]

My Take on the Show Last Night

1) Uche- In the beginning he wasn't very clear, the song wasn't very good either. I Thought it was a below average vocal, with a overdone performance at the end. Grade D+

2) Laci- Another boring song choice that sucked the life out of the performance. A slightly below average vocal with a boring song. Forgettable. Grade C-

3) Alejandro- Another brutal vocal. I don't get what people are seeing here I have to be honest. Grade D-

4) Alyssa- Finally a good performance and a beautiful song, and a very good vocal. Grade B+

5) Wade- Another good song choice, did a really solid vocal on the song. I have my doubts that he will be able to have his voice hold up and pick songs that work well with his voice. But that doesn't matter yesterday as he was very good. Grade B+

6) Dimitirus- A solid vocal for the most part, a few pitch issues, but overall a good song choice and decent vocal. Grade B-

7) Walker- Another boring song choice, with just an average vocal. Grade C

8) Madison- That is a very difficult song to sing in my opinion the highest degree of difficulty on the night, and she made it look easy. I thought it was a great vocal and song choice. Grade A

9) Laine- I thought it was a pretty solid vocal, with a solid song choice. Very good performance. Grade B+

10) Jeremiah- Not a perfect song or vocal, as there were some pitch issues along the way, but also hit some good notes too. Slightly Above Average. Grade C+

My two that should be eliminated
Uche
Alejandro

They Eliminated
Uche
Dimitirus

They decided not to use the judges save which I agreed with.

Although I think dimitrius was decent last night, I also think that is the best he will probably do, because he is a bit of a inconsistent vocalist during every song. I'm convinced the winner should come from Madison or Laine, right now Alyssa would be my third choice, but I think she is not very popular to say the least for some unknown reason, she is one of the few that really can sing well and is consistent week to week. All is just my opinion of course.