InvestorsHub Logo

Raider21

02/02/19 7:01 AM

#54799 RE: Z Money #54798

Quote: If you're authentic/experienced you'll know exactly why a seasoned professional will tell you that all your "theories" about Melbourne are impossible, and why you're flat out wrong.
_____________________________________________________________________-

Yes, I do indeed know the entire history of the Edmund Fitzgerald. So what?

As to the "authentic/experience" quote cited above, what a very loose statement on your part. Very much to the contrary I do say. You have totally dismissed the testimonial research that had been produced by renowned researcher
Goin "Jack" Haskins respective to how the 1715 Concepcion sank, where, and the survivor testimonies. You totally disregard the fact that the SFRX presumed area believed to contain the remains of the "Concepcion" is completely devoid of typical ferro-magnetic targets (anomalies) that are consistent with Spanish Colonial period shipwreck sites. Something you would't know if you were never involved in performing marine magnetometer surveys. Oh yes, there were the twenty, thirty or forty iron spikes that were found, spikes that once undoubtedly held together the wooden "flotsam" that carried upon it the few survivors along with content such as a still attached cannon, and a sprinkling of cultural materials; a few silver plates, a pistol, etc., etc. Even the conclusions rendered by the hired gun archaeologists do not contradict my concept of what occurred.

hedge_fun

02/02/19 7:01 AM

#54800 RE: Z Money #54798

What do you think about this theory?...….

Over time these wooden shipwreck sites were reduced to ballast piles
through the combined action of wind and waves, and the scrambling process became accelerated. The ‘scrambling process’ in the Muckelroy wrecking model means that the artifacts have been extracted from the shipwreck and are lying on the sea-floor or have floated away – extending the site.


Below is a screenshot from the reports submitted to the Bureau. It shows how scattered the finds have been. The comment above is also from the report. It seems to be in line with Raider's theory, don't you think?


Also, most of the artifacts were found in Area 2, not the current site.




https://www.scribd.com/document/380166633/Seafarer-Quest-2016-05-Area-1-Interim-Report-2018