Replies to post #15066 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[ONEBGG]

Good review, I agree with much, I almost put Effie in my list of good byes. BTW, Maddie sang Brand New Key pretty much the way the original artist, Melanie did.

[gail]

i extended ihub (membership) just so that i can post here until the show is over.

i have not had the time to watch it and it is important to me but some things came up, BUT i plan to watch both shows by tues night and reply here.

thx for your reviews!

[gail]

is his name rob or ron? i thought it showed his name as ron.