Are you new to baseball, ortiz doesn't even play in the field.
Jeter is the sure thing.
For the past few 3-4 seasons the yankess had 4 players over 100 RBI'S. This season the yankees lost Matsui, and shefield, That's a couple hundread RBI'S the yanks are losing this season. But yet they're in first place and there's a good chance Jeter might win the batting title. Offense alone would make him more valuable than ortiz, but he's also one of the best feilders.
My prediction: Jeter wins MVP, Golden Glove, Batting Title. World Series MVP is questionable, they have to get there first.