Nice post, Brad. But don't expect AF to accept the hard truth that there is a moral aspect to what he is doing which extends to moral responsibility for helping to delay availability of life extending or even life saving treatment, or for discouraging individual patients from treatments that could have helped them. That's way too fine a line for a guy like AF to understand, and in any case he thinks what he is doing is helping to stop any capital from being allocated to treatments which he has decided are not going to work. "What if you are wrong" is a difficult question which he will never be willing to entertain - he'd have to find a different career if he did.