Replies to post #14973 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[gail]

well, i have to say i cant not stand either of their voices. i liked only one that she did, i think it was Roll'n on the river. that was good.

and his voice, to me, is just awful, really awful but he is a good entertainer and super nice guy.

[gail]

my review on tonight's "pre" finale show.......

..

the top 3 are La'porsha, Trent, and Dalton.

they all sing but the tally is already in... Dalton gets kicked off.

so, the top 2 sing and now its round 2........

trent- didnt like it at all

laporsha- it was ok as she modulated and all,l but her vibrato is so exaggerated.

the judges talked as if she won already

round 3-

trent does a repeat song... dont like it..

Laporsha, she could do ok for a kid's disney movie song, but not for top idol.

finale' thurs night. sigh.