Replies to post #14578 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[SSKILLZ1]

This is my Review. FWIW.

Tyanna

1) Tyanna (1rst Performance)- Pitchey in parts, old fashion. Didn't love it.

Grade C-

B) Tyanna (2nd Performance)- I disagree with you. This was far worse then the 1rst one. I thought she hit a ton of bumb notes, I didn't like it.

Grade D-


Clark

1) Clark- Didn't love the start and finish thought those were not very good. Middle felt like he was drounded out. Medicore at best.

Grade C

2) Clark- Was even worse then the first one. No feeling, and flat as pancake. Worst Night we have seen from him by a country mile overall.

Grade D+

Jax

1) Jax was not very good on her 1rst Performance, Their were alot of thing wrong with that vocal and that performance.

Grade D+

2) Jax here 2nd performance she marched around the stage, but at the end of the day, song doesn't support much of a vocal, and for the most part didn't like her vocal. her worst night in my opinion by a country mile overall. Also rock music doesn't really help her very much, she should stay away from that.

Grade D+

Nick

1) Nick- I actually Liked that performance for the most part I thought he was pretty good, better in the 1rst performance for me then his second.

Grade B

2) Nick- Hit some bumb note wasn't great but still better then most on this one.

Grade C+

Quentin

1) Quentin- Well he didn't sing incredibly well, but not terrible. Then followed it up with some not so great reactions. He is not a rock singer, and that wasn't a great song for him in my opinion.

Grade C-

2) Quentin-Better song for him, having said that he didn't execute it well, as he was very pitchey (all over the place), hit a few decent notes toward the end but by then the horse was allready out of the barn.

Grade D+

Bottom two

1) Joey- Man that wasn't not very good what she did with the song.

Grade D-

2) Joey- Better then the first, and average at best.

Grade C-


Rayvon-

1) Rayvon- 1rst performance was okay, he performed, but still felt nothing. Sang okay, but had some imperfections as well.

Grade C-

2) Rayvon- The best performance of the night. I say that without a doubt in my mind not even close. he made me feel something, and excellent vocal. Good song choice for him. He is also 3/3 of escaping the bottom 2. In a way that is kind of impressive.

Grade A-

So rayvon rightfully stays.

My Bottom 2
Quentin
Tyanna

All is just my opinion, and I could always be wrong though.

[ONEBGG]

We agree on much; I think you picked the perfect word that describes Nick and it explains why I don't care for him. "Mousy."

Good job on My Funny Valentine.