Replies to post #14435 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[gail]

agree. heres my take on last nights show. i was going to post it last night but was too tired, so, here goes...

round 1-

gena- yuck, but judges raved about it.

caleb- wow! omg! and he just came off of a week where his voice was a wreck. you could tell he was about 95% back to strong. i loved the song.

round 2-

gena- yup, very good, just like when she did it before.

caleb- loved it, but judges had to nit pick it apart.

round 3-

gena- double yuck

caleb- did his own song that he wrote, but i didnt like it. i got a little bored for some reason. the judges didnt even comment on the song, they just blabbed about nothing. poor caleb. he better be the winner.

[gail]

logman, are you still on ihub? you have not posted since july. i hope everything is ok????