Replies to post #14417 on AMERICAN IDOL (IDOL)

[gail]

ok, we had 3 rounds of each singer so let's get to it..

round one (ding ding ding)----

caleb- the song pace was too slow. it was a rock song but needed to speed way up imo.

jessica- yuck!!!!!!!

alex- wow, i actually liked it and he had the most emotion of all season. very good. yet, 2 of the judges didnt like it.

jena- she did good yet the judges ragged her. go figure.

round two-------------

caleb- did ccr's travelin' band (and i have always loved this song).. wow, omg, he was fantastic!!!!!!

jessica- it was good. but she kind of just stood there. then the judges squashed her. i felt bad for her.

jena- it was ok but ehh... the light show was amazing.

alex- uh oh, a bit off beat,, he struggled, was out of breath, it was uncomfy for me to watch.

round 3 ------------

caleb- i worried about him doing a softer song, since his one and only other one, was off key imo. but he did very good, and that 3d light show was off the charts. i dont think i have seen that before.

jessica- it was good

jena- she was at the piano, and did a fantastic job of elvis's song. but sadly, not sure if you all saw it, but there was a blip and someone was talking? sounded like the host?? so it cut part of her song out. it was her best ever, imo. i just hope, for her sake, that they have the full tape of it, without someone interrupting and being bleeped out or whatever that was.

alex- it was just ok. yet, they loved it.