World Surveillance Group Inc (fka WSGI)

[indyjonesohio]

Key phrase in a recent article on the USAF airship programs:

The Air Force's recent experiment in intelligence sensor fusion known as the Blue Devil program is in the process of winding down -- but congressional interest in the effort remains high, with recently approved legislation on Capitol Hill urging the Air Force to develop a plan for a replacement system within months.

"within months"

Here is the article:

INSIDE DEFENSE article

'Operational demonstration' ended Dec. 31

USAF Winds Down Blue Devil Program While Preparing Response To Hill


Posted on InsideDefense.com: January 22, 2014


The Air Force's recent experiment in intelligence sensor fusion known as the
Blue Devil program is in the process of winding down -- but congressional
interest in the effort remains high, with recently approved legislation on
Capitol Hill urging the Air Force to develop a plan for a replacement system
within months.

Widely known as a failed attempt to utilize airships to perform persistent
intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance missions, Blue Devil is more
accurately described as a fused sensor package mounted on a variety of
platforms that is able share wide-area motion imagery, signals intelligence
and other kinds of data with tactical units in close to real time. Blue
Devil has been classified as an "operational demonstration," not a program
of record, and is broken into two separate efforts: Blue Devil I
successfully operated those sensors on a group of aging fixed-wing aircraft
in Afghanistan, while Blue Devil II tried to adapt that technology package
onto an airship, with poor results.

According to a trio of Air Force officials, who spoke with Inside the Air
Force on background, Blue Devil I was fielded quickly in 2010 in response to
a request from U.S. Central Command to support troops on the ground trying
to counter improvised explosive devices. The group of four King Air A90
aircraft, which date back to the 1970s, operated almost continuously from
the fall of 2010 until the end of 2013, when CENTCOM deemed the Blue Devil I
mission no longer necessary as part of the Pentagon's broader drawdown from
Afghanistan.

"The actual demonstration has concluded as of 31 December . . . and the
airplanes are on their way home," one of the officials said. The Air Force
is just beginning the process of assessing the program and its lessons
learned, as well as determining a new application for the collection of
sensors that made Blue Devil effective in theater within the Air Force
Research Lab or other organizations, another said. That sensor package is
government property.

The aircraft, however, are not. Five King Air aircraft -- four deployed and
one used as a spare or for testing in the United States -- were originally
leased by the Air Force from contractor SAIC in 2006 as part of a program
known as Angel Fire that deployed to Iraq. The service considered multiple
acquisition strategies for those platforms pending the need to continue the
Blue Devil I mission. But with the operational demonstration over, the Air
Force decided neither to purchase them nor to extend their lease, which
congressional limitations on the length of a lease may have prevented
regardless. The aircraft are being returned to Leidos, a company that spun
off from SAIC since the lease was initiated and now owns the airplanes,
early this year.

"The program was put together for, 'What can we do quickly at modest cost
for an urgent capability?'" one of the officials said. "It was not, 'What
makes sense in the long term and what is the most sustainable,
cost-effective approach?' When the urgent need is gone, you have to step
back and say, 'Now what makes sense for me and for the future?' And keeping
these old A90s is probably not the right answer."

Congress watching

Despite CENTCOM's directive to wrap up Blue Devil activities in theater,
Congress has clearly expressed its desire that the Air Force maintain the
ability to perform wide-area, multi-sensor ISR missions, be it with Blue
Devil I aircraft or other platforms. The fiscal year 2014 Defense
Authorization Act and the omnibus appropriations legislation passed by the
House and Senate last week both include language to that affect.

According to the authorizing legislation, signed by President Obama in
December, the secretary of the Air Force must "develop a plan to sustain the
operational capabilities of the Blue Devil I ISR Systems, including
precision signal geolocation, by procuring the existing Blue Devil I
aircraft, developing a new system, or adapting and integrating capabilities
from existing and development programs." That gives the Air Force some
flexibility in that it has not been ordered to purchase the exact aircraft
used for Blue Devil I. Still, the legislative provision mandates that the
service keep up the capability in some form -- an obligation that may
coincide with service goals to expand ISR capabilities and retain multi-role
aircraft fleets.

The recently passed omnibus appropriations bill backs up that authorizing
provision with money. According to the bill, the Air Force requested $37.8
million for research and development into "airborne reconnaissance systems"
and was given that amount plus an extra $10 million to look into a Blue
Devil replacement with wide-area motion imagery and near-vertical,
direction-finding signals intelligence capabilities. President Obama signed
the appropriations bill into law on Jan. 17.

The authorization bill also requests that the Air Force describe the cost of
procuring and operating a Blue Devil-like system and a listing of similar
programs already in the works by the Air Force or the Defense Advanced
Research Projects Agency. Air Force spokeswoman Maj. Mary Danner-Jones said
in a Jan. 17 email that the service was given 90 days after the enactment of
the authorization bill to prepare that response to Congress, giving it until
around March 26 to finalize the plan.

Neither bill makes any mention of the airship concept that was represented
in Blue Devil II, instead focusing on the "precision signal geolocation"
capability that Blue Devil I demonstrated, albeit in a permissive airborne
environment with unique weather and other characteristics. One of the
officials noted that the system was optimized for Afghanistan's "urban
desert" environment, and that it may not work as well in other climates or
terrains.

The Air Force refused to comment on its plans for adapting Blue Devil-style
sensors for future use until it submits a formal response to members of
Congress. The service does own other relatively small, fixed-wing manned
aircraft, plus a growing fleet of unmanned planes, that could potentially
take on this technology, and the officials mentioned the MC-12 Liberty and
MQ-9 Reaper as possible hosts for the sensor package.

Operational and policy challenges

The officials acknowledged a handful of challenges in fielding and operating
the Blue Devil fleet in Afghanistan, primary among them the process of
getting clearance to share data at various classification levels with
members of a multinational military coalition.

First off, the sensors on board the aircraft were collecting some data, such
as signals intelligence information, that is more sensitive than others,
like imagery of largely uninhabited terrain. That meant the data fused
together by the Blue Devil package had multiple "data guards" and levels of
security.

The second and perhaps more critical issue was ensuring that data was
classified and distributed appropriately to troops in battle. One of the
officials acknowledged that there is a tendency to overclassify intelligence
information; in this case, though, classifying too many data packages as
"top secret" would have prevented soldiers on the ground from accessing
them, so there was an effort made to properly define information as top
secret, secret or at other levels.

"You've got to be able to push product out at the appropriate
classification, so you can't just classify everything at the highest level
and just leave it there, because then people who do need it -- typically the
gunfighters walking around the cities are not [top secret] cleared," he
said. "A lot of them are barely secret and that's all they need, so they
wouldn't get the data. So you have to be able to package the data
appropriately for the level of classification the customer needs."

Adding yet more complexity to the situation, ISR collected by Blue Devil I
aircraft needed to be distributed not only to Americans but to partner
nation troops participating in the war in Afghanistan and to Afghans
themselves. That demanded a further level of security and scrutiny.

Aside from data security, the officials described writing the software that
enabled Blue Devil's sensor fusion capabilities as a technical challenge.
However, because the program was an operational demonstration, there was
some latitude in being able to constantly refresh or improve the software in
the field over time.

Last, the officials described the King Air A90's leasing situation as
somewhat problematic because by statute, aircraft can only be leased for up
to five years. In the past, Congress had granted the Blue Devil program a
six-month extension to continue its lease with Leidos, but a continuing
lease arrangement would have required special permission from Congress.

All told, the officials viewed the operational demonstration as a success
both as an examination of airborne sensor fusion technologies, and as an
effective counter-IED platform.

"[Blue Devil] was very useful to the warfighter, and in a sense, it was the
first integrated multi-INT platform that we had fielded over there," one of
the officials said. "There's many multi-sensor platforms, but they're not
necessarily integrated. This was the first attempt to fuse and integrate on
board the platform." -- Gabe Starosta