300 game winner matchups In 1982 Don Sutton and Gaylord Perry faced each other in the first matchup of 300 game winners since Pud Galvin faced Tim Keefe in 1892. Sutton also pitched in the last 4 matchups of 300 game winners ... vs. Steve Carlton ('86) vs. Tom Seaver ('86) vs. Phil Neikro ('86 and '87)