All of my information is anecdotal. Then again, most local real estate stuff tends to be private, hence anecdotal.
I'm told by people I know that prices are "high" on the Lake. There are a lot of grand homes there, and to me, they are expensive.
In this case, I'd agree with the realtor.
Now, if you're talking about 'just a house' built in one of the developments away from the Lake, but in / near Canandaigua, that's different, and probably over priced. But, no where near over-priced like Las Vegas or S. Florida condos.
Best I got. DYODD. Good luck.
rr