InvestorsHub Logo
Followers 69
Posts 6508
Boards Moderated 0
Alias Born 02/10/2010

Re: GetSeriousOK post# 313523

Saturday, 05/06/2023 5:59:32 PM

Saturday, May 06, 2023 5:59:32 PM

Post# of 330577
That's one opinion on the issue

The SEC had been warned for years prior to the Lucia Lawsuit that their hiring and firing power over their Administrative Law Judges was unconstitutional. Judges need to be free from any influence that would sway their decisions, Administrative Law Judges were not

The Judges had pressure placed on them by the SEC to return convictions which resulted in a 90% conviction rate vs similar cases tried by Federal Judges which had a 65% conviction rate.

When the SCOTUS Lucia judgement ruled that hundreds of ALJ trial decisions were invalid due to being decided by unconstitutional Judges the SEC had copious amounts of egg on their face.

The original judgement against BIEL, over $1.6 million, was abandoned for a new amount of $160k. BIEL knew that going through the laborious process of another SEC trial would cost them more in legal fees than the SEC settlement offer of $160k so they agreed.