AMERICAN IDOL

[gail]

my take on the show…..

….

so, its about 2am my time in va, and i just watched the first (of the two) shows since they are so long… i will catch up on the duets one hopefully tomorrow night (wed night that is).. so here is my take on this one here…

i think i missed a couple of them as i fast forwarded, then backed up, then played the show, but i do think i missed a couple of them..

- nutsa- very good
- sarah- was just ok.. then she quit, as you said, and i was fine with it, just let her leave.
- marybeth- it was good
- zach- hated it and way too mousy
- hannah- it was pretty good
- We’- excellent! but i dont buy the fake regular voice, i just dont. time will tell if she slips up, but the singing was great.
- lyric (who names their kid this? or did she change her name? lol)- horrible, hated it
- mckayla- nope
- haven- it was good but too sappy.
- matt- no, but the judges loved it but then, they loved all of them.
- oliver- i love chris stapleton songs but i didnt like his version of it.
- fire, again, who names these kids?? nope, didnt like the song
- lucy- hmm… not impressed but the judges gushed over it.
- brayden- NO
- mariah- nope
- trey- loved it! he was a little pitchy but it just hit me as good.
- emma- wow, she was oddly good, scary, and then oddly really good again. lol. she could do a 007 movie cover song! i truly believe that.
- kamron- no
- megan- i wanted to love it but it was just ok
- dawson- hated it, and too “snowflaky” just like he is. i try to put that all aside and hear the song but the song was crap.
- kya- too churchy for me but they love screaming churchy stuff. so…..
- Iam- it was good, not great but i know that (ihubber) b-rich, who chimed in a couple times, wants him to win. but he needs to at least wear some clothes and try to be presentable. yes, he is from Hawaii, we get it, but just put some clothes on. sigh.

its late so i do plan to watch part 2, wed night. stay tuned.