Thursday, March 25, 2021 9:42:56 PM
InterDigital asked the court to “require Lenovo to plead its antitrust counts (as well as a breach of contract count, which is not the subject of the pending motion) as compulsory counterclaims in a patent infringement suit InterDigital is pressing in this Court.” Judge Stark granted in part and denied in part InterDigital’s motion.
Lenovo sued InterDigital in April claiming InterDigital’s patents are preventing Lenovo from satisfying industry-wide cellular standards because InterDigital purportedly refused to license its patents despite the plaintiffs’ offers to pay tens of millions of dollars. These patents are reportedly essential for 3G and 4G wireless standards, under fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND) licensing obligations. As a result, the plaintiffs asserted antitrust claims against InterDigital.
The court noted that to plead antitrust standing, “a plaintiff must allege an injury that antitrust law seeks to prevent.” Judge Stark asserted that Lenovo met this requirement. “Lenovo’s allegations that it will be forced out of the cellular market or forced to pay higher-than-FRAND royalties are sufficient to state an injury caused by InterDigital taking action prohibited by the antitrust laws. That is, the injuries Lenovo claims it is suffering could not have occurred unless InterDigital has committed some type of antitrust law violation.” Moreover, the judge said that Lenovo alleged InterDigital “is already injuring it by presently demanding supra-FRAND royalties and depriving Lenovo of access to cellular technology, all because Lenovo will not satisfy InterDigital’s demands.”
The court found, however, that Lenovo failed to “plausibly allege an agreement in furtherance of a common scheme.” In particular, Judge Stark claimed that while Lenovo “tries to allege concerted action between InterDigital and ETSI and/or between InterDigital and other ETSI members, (it) has failed to do so. Lenovo does not point to an agreement between members of ETSI or any scheme resulting from such an agreement.”
The court explained that a purported unilateral breach of FRAND is not sufficient to allege actionable claims under Section 1 of the Sherman Act. Consequently, the court concluded that Lenovo has not adequately alleged a Sherman Act Section 1 claim and granted InterDigital’s motion to dismiss this claim.
However, the court found that Lenovo adequately alleged a Sherman Act Section 2 claim. Specifically, Judge Starks found that Lenovo’s claim follows those in Broadcom and adequately stated a Section 2 claim because the patent holder’s “intentionally false promise” to license the technology, along with Lenovo’s “reliance on that promise when including the technology in a standard” and a breach of that promise by InterDigital constitutes anti-competitive conduct.
The court found that Lenovo alleged what Broadcomrequires, specifically “that InterDigital lied to ETSI about its commitment to FRAND licensing in order to obtain the benefit of SEP status for its patent portfolio, thereby unlawfully obtaining market power which InterDigital now seeks to exploit for its own gain.” Thus, the court proclaimed that these allegations are sufficient for a Section 2 claim and therefore denied InterDigital’s motion to dismiss these claims.
The court also stated that this action is a compulsory counterclaim “to InterDigital’s first-filed patent infringement action against Lenovo, which is … also pending in this District.” The court stated that Lenovo’s breach of contract claim in this instant action and InterDigital’s declaratory judgment that it did not breach the same contract in the patent action are “logically related,” although the scope is different.
The court added that Lenovo’s Section 2 claim is a compulsory counterclaim “because it arises out of the same facts and occurrences as the patent infringement claims filed by InterDigital in the earlier action.” Moreover, the opinion noted, “findings in the patent infringement action as to whether Lenovo infringes InterDigital’s asserted patents could impact issues raised in Lenovo’s action here.” The court stated that since both actions “are logically related() and have evidentiary overlap…Lenovo’s claims must be pled as compulsory counterclaims in InterDigital’s patent infringement action.” As a result, the court added that it will order the two cases to be consolidated.
Lenovo and Motorola are represented by Morris, Nichols, Arsht & Tunnell LLP.
InterDigital is represented by Smith, Katzenstein & Jenkins LLP and Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati.
"Intellectuals solve problems; geniuses prevent them." - Albert Einstein
Recent IDCC News
- Form 11-K - Annual report of employee stock purchase, savings and similar plans • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/20/2024 12:30:40 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/12/2024 08:10:56 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/12/2024 08:10:42 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/12/2024 08:10:29 PM
- Form 144 - Report of proposed sale of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/11/2024 09:26:41 PM
- Form 144 - Report of proposed sale of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/11/2024 08:51:28 PM
- Form 144 - Report of proposed sale of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/11/2024 08:42:45 PM
- InterDigital and Philips to Showcase Volumetric Streaming Technologies Empowering Immersive Sports Experiences at AWE USA 2024 • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 06/11/2024 08:00:00 AM
- Form 8-K - Current report • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/10/2024 08:30:24 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/10/2024 08:09:07 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/10/2024 08:06:53 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/10/2024 08:04:08 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/10/2024 08:01:44 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/07/2024 08:13:30 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/07/2024 08:10:01 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/07/2024 08:07:53 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/07/2024 08:06:54 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 06/07/2024 08:05:55 PM
- InterDigital Declares Regular Quarterly Cash Dividend • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 06/06/2024 08:30:00 PM
- InterDigital to Present at Upcoming Conferences • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 05/30/2024 12:30:00 PM
- Form 144 - Report of proposed sale of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 05/06/2024 08:06:54 PM
- InterDigital Announces Financial Results for First Quarter 2024 • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 05/02/2024 12:30:08 PM
- InterDigital awarded injunction against Lenovo • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 05/02/2024 12:30:00 PM
- InterDigital’s Doug Castor Elected Co-Chair of the ATIS Next G Alliance Steering Group • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 04/29/2024 08:00:00 AM
- New Report Pins 6G Success on Novel Benchmarks Extending Beyond Speed, Latency, and Mobility • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 04/25/2024 08:00:00 AM
FEATURED POET Wins "Best Optical AI Solution" in 2024 AI Breakthrough Awards Program • Jun 26, 2024 10:09 AM
HealthLynked Promotes Bill Crupi to Chief Operating Officer • HLYK • Jun 26, 2024 8:00 AM
Bantec's Howco Short Term Department of Defense Contract Wins Will Exceed $1,100,000 for the current Quarter • BANT • Jun 25, 2024 10:00 AM
ECGI Holdings Targets $9.7 Billion Equestrian Apparel Market with Allon Brand Launch • ECGI • Jun 25, 2024 8:36 AM
Avant Technologies Addresses Progress on AI Supercomputer-Driven Data Centers • AVAI • Jun 25, 2024 8:00 AM
Green Leaf Innovations, Inc. Expands International Presence with New Partnership in Dubai • GRLF • Jun 24, 2024 8:30 AM