Tuesday, April 24, 2018 11:44:40 AM
Share us on: By Ryan Davis
Law360 (April 24, 2018, 10:13 AM EDT) -- The U.S. Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that America Invents Act reviews do not violate the U.S. Constitution and that the Patent Trial and Appeal Board has the authority to invalidate patents, leaving intact a system that has been used to challenge thousands of patents.
The U.S. Supreme Court has rejected an argument that only federal courts can find patents invalid, upholding the authority of the Patent Trial and Appeal Board and the constitutionality of America Invents Act reviews. (Law360)
In a 7-2 opinion, the high court rejected an argument by Oil States Energy Services LLC — which had appealed an AIA inter partes review decision invalidating its hydraulic fracturing patent — that only federal courts, not executive branch tribunals like the PTAB, can find patents invalid.
AIA reviews are simply a method for the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, of which the PTAB is a part, to review its own decision to issue a patent, and do not present any constitutional concerns, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote for the majority.
"This court has recognized, and the parties do not dispute, that the decision to grant a patent is a matter involving public rights — specifically, the grant of a public franchise," he wrote. "Inter partes review is simply a reconsideration of that grant, and Congress has permissibly reserved the PTO's authority to conduct that reconsideration."
Oil States' patent was found invalid in an inter partes review requested by Greene's Energy Group LLC, and the decision was affirmed by the Federal Circuit.
In its Supreme Court brief, Oil States maintained that that the AIA review system “impermissibly transfers the responsibility for deciding common-law suits from Article III judges to administrative agency employees who are beholden to executive branch officials — precisely the evil the framers sought to avoid.”
The USPTO responded that the PTAB’s review of patents is permissible under the Constitution because it is no different from the office’s clearly constitutional authority to issue patents in the first place.
“Inter partes review serves to protect the public from the unwarranted burdens that erroneously issued patents impose,” the office said.
Since AIA reviews were established in 2012, they have become a key tool used by accused infringers to challenge patents.
According to PTAB statistics, the board had received nearly 8,000 petitions challenging patents in AIA reviews through the end of 2017, and had issued just over 1,900 final decisions, 81 percent of which found at least one claim of the patent invalid.
The large volume of PTAB decisions finding patents invalid sparked widespread outcry among patent owners. They argued that the board is biased in favor of invalidating patents and set their sights of having AIA reviews eliminated completely on constitutional grounds.
At oral arguments in November, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg signaled that the court might lean toward keeping the reviews in place.
"There must be some means by which the patent office can correct the errors that it's made," she said.
Attorneys for the parties could not immediately be reached for comment.
The patent-in-suit is U.S. Patent Number 6,179,053.
Oil States is represented by Allyson N. Ho, C. Erik Hawes and Judd D. Stone of Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP.
Greene’s is represented by Christopher Kise, Joshua Hawkes, Pavan Agarwal, David Goroff, George E. Quillin, Lawrence Dougherty and Bradley D. Roush of Foley & Lardner LLP.
The government is represented by Noel Francisco, Chad A. Readler, Malcolm Stewart, Rachel Kovner, Mark R. Freeman and William E. Havemann of the U.S. Department of Justice, and Sarah Harris, Nathan Kelley, Thomas Krause, Farheena Rasheed and Mary Beth Walker of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
The case is Oil States Energy Services LLC v. Greene’s Energy Group LLC, case number 16-712, in the Supreme Court of the United States.
--Editing by Rebecca Flanagan.
Recent IDCC News
- InterDigital Wins Two CSI Awards for Best Immersive Video and Video Processing Technology • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 09/16/2024 12:30:00 PM
- InterDigital Announces Annual Recurring Revenue Target Of $1 Billion By 2030 • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 09/16/2024 12:00:00 PM
- Interdigital Announces Increase of Regular Quarterly Cash Dividend • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 09/10/2024 12:00:00 PM
- At 6GSymposium, InterDigital to Lead Crucial Discussions on Emerging Use Cases and Avenues Towards 6G Profitability • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 09/09/2024 08:00:00 AM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 09/06/2024 08:05:00 PM
- Form 144 - Report of proposed sale of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 09/05/2024 08:01:37 PM
- InterDigital to Showcase Excellence in Broadcast and Immersive Video Solutions at IBC 2024 • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 08/29/2024 08:00:00 AM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 08/22/2024 12:17:49 PM
- Form 144 - Report of proposed sale of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 08/20/2024 08:06:55 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 08/20/2024 01:05:55 PM
- More than half of connected devices will be haptic enabled by 2028, revealing exciting opportunity for immersive video • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 08/20/2024 08:00:00 AM
- Form 144 - Report of proposed sale of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 08/19/2024 08:19:03 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 08/19/2024 12:28:06 PM
- InterDigital Announces 2024 Investor Day • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 08/01/2024 12:45:00 PM
- Form 10-Q - Quarterly report [Sections 13 or 15(d)] • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 08/01/2024 12:35:02 PM
- Form 8-K - Current report • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 08/01/2024 12:32:54 PM
- Interdigital Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter 2024 • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 08/01/2024 12:30:21 PM
- InterDigital signs license agreement with Panasonic • GlobeNewswire Inc. • 08/01/2024 08:30:00 AM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 07/26/2024 12:52:36 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 07/26/2024 12:48:39 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 07/26/2024 12:47:00 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 07/26/2024 12:45:22 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 07/26/2024 12:40:30 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 07/26/2024 12:37:32 PM
- Form 4 - Statement of changes in beneficial ownership of securities • Edgar (US Regulatory) • 07/26/2024 12:31:56 PM
Lingerie Fighting Championships Signs Broadcast Deal With Maybacks Global Entertainment • BOTY • Sep 26, 2024 9:00 AM
Maybacks Global Entertainment and Lingerie Fighting Championships Enter Into Broadcast And Revenue Sharing Agreement • AHRO • Sep 26, 2024 8:30 AM
North Bay Resources Commences Operations at Bishop Gold Mill, Inyo County, California; Engages Sabean Group Management Consulting • NBRI • Sep 25, 2024 9:15 AM
CEO David B. Dorwart Anticipates a Bright Future at Good Gaming Inc. Through His Most Recent Shareholder Update • GMER • Sep 25, 2024 8:30 AM
Cannabix Technologies and Omega Laboratories Inc. Advance Marijuana Breathalyzer Technology - Dr. Bruce Goldberger to Present at Society of Forensic Toxicologists Conference • BLOZF • Sep 24, 2024 8:50 AM
Integrated Ventures, Inc Announces Strategic Partnership For GLP-1 (Semaglutide) Procurement Through MedWell USA, LLC. • INTV • Sep 24, 2024 8:45 AM