XpresSpa Group Inc (XSPA)

[JIMWJ]

Not sure about that simply because Chen headed the US patent office
until 2013. That means these patents were validated on his watch.Google then went on to unsuccessfully write a workaround that failed. I would say copying is rather clear.

Vringo unequivocally proved infringement "copying" during the trial so I smell a rat here and I suspect it is Bloomberg editors.