Replies to post #42279 on XpresSpa Group Inc (XSPA)

[NlikeFlynn]

Yes, that is exactly what happened. Now Lets stop talking about laches, it's done and over with and we are probably never going to get anything out of it unless appealed.

[postyle]

Let me help you refresh your memory:

PACER 767: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION FOR JUDGMENT AS A MATTER OF LAW OF LACHES

Enjoy!

I do not remember Google asking for latches as part of their defense. I believe the Judge invoked latches on his own as he felt that the Patent holder had slept on the patent and as a result the defense was in a worse position then they would have been had the patent holder filed a claim earlier.My position is long VRNG.