Without even knowing who sent the emails anything like a reasonable judgement is impossible.
I would not that one poster here received a ready response from an email on a subject that others were complaining about not receiving any response from. But he has a consist history of being reasonable and objective in the way he phrased things whereas those without the response had a history that was quite otherwise.
If I don't know WHO sent the emails, AFAIAC, it means absolutely nothing. All it is is a second hand report of a rumor of a rumor.