Hap. You obviously do not understanding beneficial financing. What Mel Karmazin did was quite rare. He did that before he became an insider because it would have been quite restrictive to do so afterward.
I am not a appologist for anyone. Management buying on the open market would be just plan dumb in this instance.
You are simply a clever basher using some of the oldest tricks in the book to support your point of view regardless of the validity of your position. Asking for what you know is not going to happen is one of those tricks. Try harder.