Replies to post #47914 on Liberty Star Uranium and Metals Corp (LBSR)

[PURA VIDA]

Much sooner than you realize, why have you changed your opinion, you used to be very LONG the stock.

Yes, we need both sides of the coin presented, I just would like to know what has MUTED your opinion about LBSR's potential, and why you think the minerals they have - HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH THEM.

Just wondering ....

S4

Could be a number of reasons, but, I would like to hear it from you. I have my suspicions.

[TradeWolf]

That's not exactly true. Any valuation of the company, no matter how discounted for risk, needs a factual jumping-off point. That factual point would be the value of the commodities that LBSR has the claims to.

You can cut it or discount it any way you want - but the fundamental value of LBSR is based on the value of its commodities - including Copper.

[HKipp1]

Well, I think you're completely wrong there. Of course, Liberty doesn't have commodities to sell. And since it doesn't have proven hard assets, it's hard to say that this varies with the commodity prices. But since the market value is based in part on what investors anticipate versus the perceived risk, they are willing to bid more if those anticipated assets are worth more based on increased commodity prices. That expectation is what helps determines the pps. Obviously there are many other factors that determine the share price, as we've all discussed numerous times. But the expectation of the company's assets being worth more, because of future commodity price increases, is obviously a factor that positively influences investors and thus the share price.

[FatElvis]

I have to agree with Crystalballz here to a point. Share price is dependant on whether or not LBSR can turn a profit. Even though all evidence points toward LBSR having minerals on its land, it's not a fact until the drilling proves it. Also,there's the chance that LBSR runs out of money and is unable to raise it. Not likely but still a possibility and right now the market is putting a very low pps on this company since it knows that penny stocks go out of business all the time due to many different reasons,some you don't even think of....think Bre-X. So although it's nice to know that the commodities that we think we have are valuable, the truth is day to day fluctuations of gold and copper have ALMOST zero to do with the pps of LBSR.

Ah thank you....thank you very much.....now time for a cheeseburger.