Any reason why you can not post the screen shot the way you did for 9/6??? If you just checked, you can go back and make a screenshot now. Your payment is valid for 24 hours.
It's not guesswork when you've seen this situation happen over and over again. It's common sense and if you play and pay attention to the way this operates you will get a feel for how they pull it off.
Here's a great description of what happens in these scenarios: