Replies to post #3505 on QID - QLD TRENDS (fka )

[blasher]

awesome! Larry. .. I will soon provide this indicator. I already keep a database of all NYSE, NASDAQ, & AMEX stocks .. it'll be easy for me to generate this signal.

this is great!

[ReturntoSender]

Larry, do you believe the data referred to on the 10 day sma's is reliable in that article? It might be but any quick and violent sell off is likely to result in 90% of stocks being below their 10 day sma. But maybe this is good data. What if it is not?

I wanted to run some charts to confirm it but I cannot. The best I can do is show you with some charts that this opinion and data needs confirmation from the 50 day and 200 day sma's to be considered accurate. So in the next post I will show you what you should be looking for as confirmation using the correct sma's and record percentages on the 50 and 200 day sma's.

RtS

[ReturntoSender]

I question the veracity of this write up. I believe that only when 90% of stocks are below their 10, 50 and 200 day sma's can you safely suggest the market 2 weeks, 3 months and a year later. We are not seeing a major market bottom now in my humble opinion. RtS

Amid Naysayers, an Upbeat View
By Jon D. Markman
RealMoney.com Contributor
1/14/2005 4:41 PM EST URL:

http://www.thestreet.com/funds/jondmarkman/10203518.html

Editor's Note: This is a bonus story from Jon Markman, whose commentary usually appears only on RealMoney. We're offering it today to TheStreet.com readers. To read Jon Markman's commentary regularly, please click here for information about a free trial to RealMoney.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Virtually every major technical analysis shop and market timer in the country has declared the 2004 rally dead in the water over the past two weeks. But Florida-based Lowrys Reports is one exception. The firm has a great long-term record, so it's worth hearing its point of view.

I have mentioned the institutional advisory firm, of which I am a client, before. It is objectively focused on proprietary equity supply-and-demand measures. It was appropriately bearish during the 2000-2002 bear run and has caught turns back to bullishness beautifully -- first in mid-October 2003 and then with a timely and long-lasting bullish call in late March 2003. The firm was bullish, particularly on mid-caps and small-caps, all the way through the last three quarters of 2003 and into 2004. It remains so today.

I had a long talk on Wednesday with John Brooks, who has been at Lowry's since the early 1970s. He said that his team studies 145 market indicators, and he sees nothing more on the weekly charts today than a normal correction to the bull trend. He says that most of their short-term indicators are four-fifths of the way to oversold or better, and are thus very nearly ready for a full reversal.

Brooks notes that most of his clients, at funds large and small throughout the country, were skeptical of the bull market throughout 2004 and are thus somewhat happy to be vindicated with the recent selloff. In October and even November, amid the big speculative end-of-year run, he said, it was "like pulling teeth" to get people to buy stocks. So it's not a surprise to him to learn that so many managers are exhibiting a morose skepticism today.
Confident Against the Herd

Brooks is confident that sellers will be as wrong today as they were in October last year. The percentage of NYSE and Nasdaq stocks below their 10-day moving average is one indicator that he says has given almost perfect signals for the past 20 years, and it is giving a very clear buy signal now: When that number goes below 10% (i.e., 90% of all stocks are trading below their 10-day moving average), the market is typically much higher three to six months down the road. It was at the same level in August last year, and since 1990, the signal has tripped 15 times. On average, the market is up 4% two weeks later, up 11% three months later and up 24% one year later.

Through the end of Thursday's trading session, the number of stocks below their 10-day moving average had begun to hook up despite the decline in the broad indexes -- the type of divergence that sets up reversals.

Brooks says he believes the psychology of pros has been negative for a year, and most have wanted to be defensive. This explains why Lowrys' "selling pressure" index has hit record lows while "buying power" never gained a lot of traction.

Major fund managers were holding on to their stocks, expecting higher prices, but they weren't buying a lot of new stocks. That is pretty much the definition of a "wall of worry," and it can be very bullish as fearful investors are slowly but surely tempted to commit more funds to stocks.

Brooks thinks the Dow Jones Industrials will hit 11,700 midyear, then decline and rebound to finish the year at the same level. But that doesn't mean he is a long-term bull. In fact, he believes the market is tracing out secular bear-market behavior, and he believes the current period is more like 1971-1972 -- about a year from the brink of a precipice -- than 1982, the start of a long-term rally.

For now, he says Lowrys' work has shown over the years that you can't get a major decline without a buildup in selling pressure. In the second stage of a bull market, which is probably where we are headed, he says buying power and selling pressure move up in tandem as people are increasingly willing to liquidate positions. But even when selling pressure crosses above buying power, he says that's only a four- to six-month warning of a top ahead.

In sum, Brooks advises investors to stay focused on the healthy weekly advance-decline line, which suggests continued interest in buying a broad range of stocks. "When IBM gets to $101," he says, "every trader who's been sitting on his hands is going to say, 'What do I do now?' And then you're going to get a melt-up. The glass is not half empty, it's half full. .... This is not the start of a bear market. All that has happened is they've taken the cream off the top of the bottle."

If you like Brooks' view better than the nabobs of negativity, here are the big-cap stocks he likes.

Big-Caps Poised to Perform

Company Ticker
IBM (IBM:NYSE)
Wyeth (WYE:NYSE)
Altria (MO:NYSE)
Caterpillar (CAT:NYSE)
Disney (DIS:NYSE)
United Technologies (UTX:NYSE)
DuPont (DD:NYSE)
Johnson & Johnson (JNJ:NYSE)
General Electric (GE:NYSE)
Procter & Gamble (PG:NYSE)
American Express (AXP:NYSE)
American International Group (AIG:NYSE)
McDonald's (MCD:NYSE)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

At the time of publication, Markman was long General Electric, although positions may change at any time.


Jon D. Markman is publisher of StockTactics Advisor, an independent weekly investment research service, as well as senior strategist and portfolio manager at Pinnacle Investment Advisors. He also writes a weekly column for CNBC on MSN Money. While Markman cannot provide personalized investment advice or recommendations, he welcomes column critiques and comments at [e-mail].

Interested in more writings from Jon Markman? Check out his newsletter, TheStreet.com Value Investor. For more information, click here.

[J Kirksey]

See my post 3351 where I say 3 to 6 mo rally as well - based more on election cycle, time of year and fundamentals than indicators.

[cy esp]

This is a bad analysis due to a sampling error. I think the result is biased towards the time frame selected for the study. The market is up over 300% from 1990 so almost any indicator that says buy will look stellar. This indicator need to be evaluated in a flat or down market, how has it done during the last 4 years?

>>indicator that he says has given almost perfect signals for the past 20 years, and it is giving a very clear buy signal now: When that number goes below 10% (i.e., 90% of all stocks are trading below their 10-day moving average), the market is typically much higher three to six months down the road. It was at the same level in August last year, and since 1990, the signal has tripped 15 times. On average, the market is up 4% two weeks later, up 11% three months later and up 24% one year later<<