My head is spinning from all the info and circumstantial evidence being presented here Janice. But I have to say it makes me feel a bit more secure that you are the lead mod here, and wanted to thank you for taking on the task.
I'm a bit surprised that both you and Bishop are keeping your thoughts/DD to yourselves - but perhaps thats wise at this point.
Re Matt: I'm only certain about one thing... it is difficult to focus on facts when so few are available, and when so many present what appears to be a breadcrumb trail that, taken as a whole, could easily sway one to abandon objectivity.
I'm still clinging to only the facts... but damned if it isn't tempting to make the leap and make a judgement call here.
FWIW, I fully endorse the idea that Matt needs to be relieved of his duties - or voluntarily withdraw from IHUB for the time being.