Johnnyv: On the other hand, I find this criticism to have merit. It is at least factual, clearly stated and specific to certain points. It is not an incredibly broadbased bashing of ST the person or his record. ST believes and I do as well (even though I have lost some money on the stock) that in the long term this stock will go higher. Having said that, I agree with you that basically speaking if it were another stock ST might have been pointing out shorting opportunities along the way and would not have been talking (technically speaking) in somewhat fuzzy terms when we reached then breached various support levels. I also think Scorry makes a good point on the information about the company that ST has shared. If there is fault, it might be shared by all in remembering that any particular analysis of performance is filtered through a human being with subjective views.