I wasn't implying anything and I apologize if my question appeared that way.[ probally did] Since you were one of the people who actually spent the money and time researching this I thought you found something that convinced you that I missed or didn't find or hadn't found yet. I was referring to the Judge's ruling where he was pretty clear in case law.[imo] .If you look back at my posts from a couple years ago I spent a lot of time and money [ even got a UK geologist's opinion on Rome's supposed oil claims.] trying to find a reason to believe in PBLS.