Replies to post #84056 on NFL - King/Queen of the Hill Pool

[The_Free_Nebula]

Definitely was a catch

[Tree]

I was borderline on that though I wanted to believe that it was a fumble. LOL!
However, I do believe in my heart of hearts that Goedert's was not a catch. He truly didn't have control until his left foot was in the air. IMHO
I was also glad that they got the out of bounds non catch overturned correctly. The ball moved when it hit the ground. I thought that they were going to screw that up
Btw, the FOX crew was just god awful. They had no idea what was going on most of the time

[Vexari]

He caught it

But they knew it couldn't stand

Must follow the script

2 scores up and momentum

Bad

The more it was reviewed

Justified the catch

Why did it take so long

Had to search the rulebook

To find a reason for it not to be a catch

Just the way I see it