Fisher got the last word and made HCMC case. HCMC found a niche market, innovated and sought and obtained patent protection on its innovation after a thorough examination before the Patent Office. HCMC should not have its rights taken from it based on the very same technology that the examiner considered in granting the patent. There is no indication that the examiner misunderstood the teaching of Robinson. HCMC’s claim should be confirmed. Thank you