Look, no one was expecting a graduate level course over a message board. You could very easily give a few counterpoints to the OP thru this forum though. You know, main idea type stuff...something to back up what your point was.
For example: "No, poster, you're wrong about COST vs. EQUITY accounting (I believe that was the topic of discussion). Taxes are figured by blah blah blah because of blah blah blah."