I have read in detail all of the major rulings and most other filings/motions in between ... I have never found anything that convinces me that the gov't is right ... never ... yet here we are ... and that, tragically, is indisputable ... and, fwiw, I am one who believes that it is HERA that is the core problem ... with too many cases where judges have used insanely contorted logic to justify their rulings ... clearly the cship itself was a complete frame job with the concrete life preserver as an accomplice ... and when the victim started to regain consciousness, the death spiral assassin was sent in ... all done in broad daylight ... so far, this has had very little to do with long established precedent, the truth and, least of all, fairness ... and when the crimes are so extreme in their brazenness and scope then, yes, I do expect that decisions for the plaintiff should be unanimous ... but we clearly do not live in that world ... and I fear scotus will have a toaster returned to us after our house has been stolen ... many thanks for all of you extensive research and highly balanced posts ... and good luck to us all