The reason there were two scenarios in the first place is because that's what the Collins plaintiffs suggested as ways to unwind the NWS.
I agree. Getting rid of the seniors is the most important move this administration can take to prevent a new one from derailing recap and release. Reinstating the seniors will be nearly impossible once they are gone.
From whatever level they trade at at that point, sure. But nothing is to say that either class will go higher or even stay the same in the meantime.
If the return of $125B is ordered by a court, it will be several years before Treasury is forced to pay it; Sweeney's cases haven't even gone to trial yet.
If Treasury voluntarily gives up the $125B sooner, they will absolutely monetize the seniors (convert them to common) to make that money back.