Replies to post #568800 on Fannie Mae (FNMA)

[obiterdictum]

Seila Law, Collins et al. and All American et al. are competing to be the vehicle by which SCOTUS can fruitfully decide on the constitutionality of a single-director structure of an independent federal agency and that the type of remedy that should apply if the single-director structure of an independent federal agency is declared unconstitutional.

In Seila Law's recent motion she argues against SCOTUS using All American or Collins as a vehicle for a ruling on constitutional and remedy questions. Collins argues it is the best vehicle since it offers both the constitutional and remedy questions, that Seila Law does not and Seila Law case "is an exceedingly poor vehicle for this Court’s review." All American argues it the one to go with for the same reasons as Collins and is willing to be a companion case with Seila Law.