Watching this video of a guy cleaning a vinyl record using glue, I couldn't help but wonder what the "copy" he made would sound like if he played it.
My guess is that it would be hideous because "new" groove would be an inverse replication of the vinyl between the grooves of the original. Even if the sound were reasonably well replicated, the left and right channels would be out of synchronization by roughly 2 seconds (for a 33 RPM record.)