VPLM provided them to simply show that they had NOTHING to do with them...
There in lies the inherent issue that Apple is claiming the patent owner had improper communication, I am sorry but Dr. Sawyer does not own these patents, nor was he responsible for the company any longer...
Are you claiming that if I go threaten a PTAB Judge that VPLM is criminally responsible because I am a shareholder?
One can argue this till the cows come home, it's called perspective and my eyes are wide open.