GATA consultant Robert Lambourne, who seems to be the only analyst outside government who studies the gold market interventions of the BIS, notes that footnotes in the BIS' monthly reports show that the bank's gold, gold swap, and gold derivative positions exploded from zero in March 2016 to 438 tonnes in March 2017 to 525 tonnes last month:
Slide 2 -- BIS / Notes to the financial statements
This page is taken from the BIS annual report issued in June, covering the year ending March 31, 2017. It acknowledges 438 tonnes of gold swaps.
Slide 3 -- BIS / Statement of account
This page, from the BIS' October 2017 statement of account, shows that the BIS' gold loans rose substantially since March last year.
What exactly is the BIS doing in the gold market and for whom?
In November I brought Lambourne's analysis to the attention of the BIS press office and asked if his analysis was correct and if the bank could explain exactly what it was doing in the gold market and for whom. The BIS press office replied:
"We do not comment on specific accounts and holdings of central banks or of the BIS. Please see our latest annual report for details on gold. Further information can be gleaned from central banks directly."
But the BIS' annual reports provide no more substantial information about its activity in the gold market than its monthly reports do. As for obtaining information about gold market activity from BIS member central banks, they are no more forthcoming.
A few years ago GATA sued the Federal Reserve in U.S. District Court in Washington for access to its gold market records. We received very little access, since the court ruled that nearly all the Fed's gold records are exempt from disclosure. Indeed, the most notable information we got by suing the Fed was the possibly inadvertent admission in writing by a member of the Fed's Board of Governors, Kevin M. Warsh, that the Fed has gold swap arrangements with foreign banks and will never disclose them.
If the swapping and leasing of gold by central banks is ordinary and innocent activity, why won't central banks disclose and explain it?
The answer to that question was given by the secret March 1999 report of the staff of the International Monetary Fund, which acknowledged that central banks conceal their gold swaps and leases to facilitate their secret interventions in the gold and currency markets:
The second biggest development in the gold price suppression scheme since we last gathered here involves the New York Commodities Exchange
Slide 6 -- NYMEX/COMEX building
-- where, GATA consultant Harvey Organ reports, thousands of gold futures contracts that have been called for delivery have been moved off the exchange in private transactions called "exchange for physicals," or EFPs.
One implication of this development is that there isn't enough gold in Comex warehouses to cover futures deliveries sought in New York and that deliveries have to be moved to London, where transactions are more easily concealed by mechanisms controlled by the London Bullion Market Association, or where long contract holders seeking delivery can be paid privately to postpone delivery.
There may be other explanations for this development, but it is recent and signifies that something big has changed about the gold market in the last year.
* * *
Perhaps not so coincidentally, as gold researcher Ronan Manly of Bullion Star in Singapore disclosed the other day, on April 1 the London Bullion Market Association --
Slide 7 -- LBMA building
-- will begin delaying its daily gold and silver auction price reports. Recently the auction price reports have been issued 30 minutes after the conclusion of the auctions. As of April 1 the auction price reports will be delayed 14 hours. The LBMA has provided no explanation for this delay, but of course the longer the reports are delayed, the more opportunity there will be to adjust or tamper with them.
Further, Manly discloses, the LBMA has postponed for another year its plan to start reporting individual trades of gold and silver. If something nefarious is going on with those "exchange for physicals" by which Comex futures contracts appear to be transferred to London, the LBMA's reporting of individual trades might reveal it. Now there will be no reporting by the LBMA of individual gold and silver trades in London for at least another year:
Also in January this year GATA disclosed the discounts that are being given by CME Group futures exchanges to governments and central banks for secretly trading gold and silver futures contracts. It is not widely understood that governments and central banks are secretly trading all futures contracts on U.S. exchanges, for mainstream financial news organizations refuse to report secret interventions in markets by governments:
But maybe all you really need to know about gold price suppression could have been surmised from a story on the front page of The Wall Street Journal on August 10 last year:
In that story the newspaper quoted four experts on the gold market, all of them associates of the Gold Anti-Trust Action Committee and all of them introduced to the newspaper's reporter by me.
Slide 11 -- Close-up of Wall Street Journal story
Those four experts -- gold researcher Ronan Manly, Sprott Asset Management's John Embry, GoldMoney founder James Turk, and futures market analyst James McShirley -- accused the Federal Reserve of being involved with the suppression of the gold price through the surreptitious lending and swapping of central bank gold reserves.
The Wall Street Journal story was a triumph for GATA, even though the Journal declined to mention GATA by name. (The reporter told GATA Chairman Bill Murphy that the newspaper just ran out of space.)
But the story would have been a much greater triumph for us -- indeed, it would have been a triumph for free markets -- if the newspaper had not decided, in reporting these complaints about surreptitious government intervention in the gold market, to violate the first rule of journalism. That's the rule about getting and reporting both sides of a story.
The Journal reported: "Some gold bugs -- investors bullish on the yellow metal -- think the Fed secretly lends it out to suppress prices, partly to protect the dollar's value. In theory the Fed can feed gold into the market through swaps with other countries."
So where were the Journal's questions about this for the Fed and the U.S. Treasury Department? Are the Fed and the Treasury Department involved in keeping the gold price down through surreptitious interventions, or are they not involved?
But the Journal never asked such questions, even though for a year and a half, as I provided the Journal's reporter with the documents of these interventions, I repeatedly pressed her to put the questions to the Fed and Treasury. I even provided the Journal's reporter with a video showing New York Federal Reserve Bank President William Dudley refusing to answer a question about gold swaps during his appearance at the Virginia Military Institute on March 31, 2016.
Note the inconsistency in Dudley's response. First he talks at length about the German Bundesbank's transactions to repatriate its gold from the New York Fed. Then, asked if the Fed is involved with gold swaps, Dudley says he can't comment on "individual customer kind of transactions." But he had just discussed an individual customer's transactions with the Fed at great length -- Germany's -- and the second question, about gold swaps, was not about individual customer transactions at all but simply whether the Fed was in the gold swap business.
Ordinarily news organizations are most interested in questions that high government officials refuse to answer. But mainstream financial news reporters are not interested in questions about secret government interventions in the gold market and secret interventions in markets generally. No, such questions are too sensitive, apparently considered threats to national security.
The best that mainstream financial news organizations can do is just to acknowledge the questions sometimes. Mainstream financial news organizations can never pursue the answers, no matter how easy it would be to do so.
Unfortunately most gold market analysts themselves will not pursue these questions either -- at least not yet. GATA will continue working on them.
Will the gold industry itself ever pursue these questions? Will the gold industry ever stand up for itself?
If not, why should anyone invest in an industry that doesn't care about the suppression of the price of its product?
Slide 13 -- Contact and thanks
The documents I have cited today are all posted at GATA's internet site, GATA.org, most of them in the "documentation" section:
If you have any trouble locating them or have any questions about GATA's work, I'll be glad to hear from you at CPowell@GATA.org.
Thanks for your kind attention.
* * *
Help keep GATA going:
GATA is a civil rights and educational organization based in the United States and tax-exempt under the U.S. Internal Revenue Code. Its e-mail dispatches are free, and you can subscribe at:
RECOMMENDED GOLD & BULLION DEALERS Coin and precious metals dealers who have supported GATA and been recommended by our supporters:
Anglo Far-East Bullion Co. Level 23, Monticello, Anastasio Ruiz N Panama City, Panama Contact: Alex Stanczyk +1-206-905-9961 newclients@anglofareast.com http://www.anglofareast.com
Aucoffre.com 9-11 Allee de l'Arche Tour Ernst & Young 92671 Courbevoie Tel: 01-80-88-48-80 Fax: 01-80-88-48-89 Contact: Jean-Franois Faure, President Contact@aucoffre.com http://www.aucoffre.com
Blanchard & Co. Inc. 909 Poydras St., Suite 1900 New Orleans, Louisiana 70112 888-413-4653 http://www.blanchardgold.com
BMG Group Inc. 280-60 Renfrew Drive Markham, Ontario L3R 0E1 Canada 888-474-1001 www.bmg-group.com info@bmg-group.com
BullionWorks 5 Sager Drive Rogers, Arkansas 72756 Contact: Ron Maines, Principal 479-790-1713 ron@bullionworks.com http://www.bullionworks.com
CMI Gold & Silver 3800 N. Central Ave. 11th Floor Phoenix, Arizona 85012 1-800-528-1380 Bill Haynes, President info@CMIGS.com http://www.cmi-gold-silver.com
Colorado Gold 222 South 5th St. Montrose, Colorado 81401 Don Stott, Proprietor 1-888-786-8822 Gold@gwe.net http://www.ColoradoGold.com
El Dorado Discount Gold 13014 N. Dale Mabry Highway Suite 133 Tampa, Florida 33618 623-643-8785 Contact: Steve Forehand steve@eldoradogold.net http://www.eldoradogold.net
Fisher Precious Metals Suite 210, 2151 West Hillsboro Blvd. Deerfield Beach, Florida 33442 800-390-8576 Contact: Lynn Fisher, Vice President Lynn@FisherPM.com https://fisherpreciousmetals.com
Gainesville Coins 17860 North U.S. Highway 41 Lutz, Florida 33549 David Kim, CFA, Proprietor 813-482-9300x337 david@gainesvillecoins.com http://www.Gainesvillecoins.com
Goldbroker.com 120 The Strand GZR1027 Gzira, Malta +356-99-057-134 Proprietor: Fabrice Drouin Ristori ceo@goldbroker.com https://www.goldbroker.com
Gold & Silver Inc. 429 Santa Monica Blvd. Santa Monica, California 90401 888-319-816-6 310-566-0730 info@goldsilver.com http://GoldSilver.com http://OroPlata.com
Goldcore 14 Fitzwilliam Square Dublin 2, Ireland +353 (0)1-632-5010 ... and ... No. 1 Cornhill London EC3V 3ND, England +44 (0)203-086-9200 Mark.OByrne@goldcore.com http://www.goldcore.com
GoldMoney Net Transactions Ltd. 1st Floor 32 Commercial St. St Helier, Jersey JE2 3RU British Channel Islands (UK) Tel: +44-1534-633-933 http://GoldMoney.com
Gold Silver Group 300 Corporate Pointe Suite 320 Culver City, California 90230 David Weishaar, Senior Account Executive Tel: 310-988-4508 (direct) Toll-free: 844-763-4046 david@goldsilvergroup.com www.goldsilvergroup.com
Investment Rarities Inc. 7850 Metro Parkway Minneapolis, Minnesota 55425 Greg Westgaard, Sales Manager 1-800-328-1860, Ext. 8889 gwestgaard@investmentrarities.com http://www.gloomdoom.com
Jaxville Gold and Silver Trading Co. 4901-48 St. Parkland Square, Lower Mall Red Deer, Alberta, Canada Jack Fortin, Owner and Operator 403-346-5266 auric@telus.net http://www.jaxville.com
Jaggards Pty Ltd. (Established 1963) Bullion and Rare Coin Dealers Level 8, 74 Pitt St. Sydney, NSW, Australia contact: Robert or Yen at +61 2 9230 0886 info@jaggards.com.au http://www.jaggards.com.au
Liberty Coin Service Bank of America Building Frandor Shopping Center 300 Frandor Ave. Lansing, Michigan 48912 Contact: Allan Beegle or Tom Coulson allanb@libertycoinservice.com 800-933-4720 or 517-351-4720 http://www.libertycoinservice.com
LINGORO.com Plaza de Carlos Trias Bertran 4, 2 28020 Madrid, Spain +34-911-86-80-90 Fax: +34-911-86-80-91 contacto@lingoro.com http://www.lingoro.com/
MRCS Canada 12303-118 Ave. NW Edmonton, Alberta T5L 2K2 Canada Michael Riedel, Proprietor 1-877-TRY-MRCS 1-877-879-6727 mrcscanada@shaw.ca http://www.mrcscanada.com
Miles Franklin Ltd. 801 Twelve Oaks Center Drive Suite 834 Wayzata, MN 55391 1-800-822-8080 Contacts: David Schectman, Andy Schectman, and Bob Sichel http://www.milesfranklin.com
Missouri Coin Co. 11742 Manchester Road St. Louis, Missouri 63131-4614 info@mocoin.com 314-965-9797 1-800-280-9797 http://www.mocoin.com
Pacific Coin Exchange 300 Carlsbad Village Drive, Suite 207 Carlsbad, California 92008 Proprietor: Phil Onori 877-917-5266 phil@pacificcoinexchange.com http://www.pacificcoinexchange.com
Resource Consultants Inc. 6139 South Rural Road Suite 103 Tempe, Arizona 85283-2929 Pat Gorman, Proprietor 1-800-494-4149, 480-820-5877 Metalguys@aol.com http://www.buysilvernow.com
Royal Crown Precious Metals Ltd. Suite 1500, HSBC Building 885 West Georgia St. Vancouver, British Columbia V6C 3E8 Canada Andreas Runge, President Toll-free: 866-769-2521 604-639-2150 Info@royalcrownmetals.com http://www.RPMetals.com
Scottsdale Bullion and Coin 14500 Northsight Blvd. Suite 204 Scottsdale, Arizona 85260 Contact: Tim Murphy Tim@sbcgold.com 602-365-0163, toll-free: 888-812-9892 http://www.sbcgold.com
Scottsdale Silver & Gold 20701 North Scottsdale Road Suite 107-266 Scottsdale, Arizona 85255 1-888-SIL-BARZ or 1-888-745-2279 sales@scottsdalesilver.com http://www.ScottsdaleSilver.com
SD Bullion 8000 Yankee Road Ottawa Lake, Michigan 49267 Contact: James Anderson, Tyler Wall 1-800-294-8732 https://SDBullion.com
Sheldon's Finest Coins P.O. Box 194 30 Noelle Court Lincoln Park, New Jersey 07035-2256 1-888-786-5678 Ed Sheldon CPA, Proprietor Agbug777@SheldonsFinestCoins.com www.SheldonsFinestCoins.com
Silver Gold Bull Inc. 4819 45th St. / Box 2612 Rocky Mountain House, Alberta T4T 1L6 Canada 877-646-5303 or 877-646-5304 Fax: 403-845-5511 Sales@SilverGoldBull.com http://www.SilverGoldBull.com
Silver Trading Co. 445 Montgomery St. PO Box 876 Shreveport, Louisiana 71107 Larry LaBorde, Proprietor 318-470-7291 LLaBord@silvertrading.net http://www.silvertrading.net
SprottMoney Ltd. Royal Bank South Tower 200 Bay St. Suite 2750, P.O. Box 90 Toronto, Ontario M5J 2J2 Canada 416-861-0775 or toll-free 888-861-0775 sales@sprottmoney.com http://www.sprottmoney.com
Swiss America Trading Corp. 15018 North Tatum Blvd. Phoenix, Arizona 85032 Dean Heskin, CEO 1-800-BUY-COIN hes@swissamerica.com http://www.swissamerica.com
The Moneychanger Box 178 Westpoint, Tennessee 38486 Franklin Sanders, Proprietor 1-888-218-9226, 931-766-6066 http://www.the-moneychanger.com
The Real Asset Co. Ltd. 2nd Floor, 8-9 Talbot Court London, England EC3V 0BP United Kingdom +44-0-207-283-1953 support@therealasset.co.uk http://therealasset.co.uk/
True Metals Group 728 West Ave., Suite 1100 Cocoa, Florida 32927 Daniel and Karina Ward, Owners 866-303-0781 Sales@silver50.com http://www.silver50.com
Worldwide Precious Metals (Canada) Ltd. Suite 1108-1030 West Georgia St. Vancouver, British Columbia, V6E 2Y3 Canada President: John P. Downes Toll-free: 1-866-623-2002 Local 778-945-2002 info@wwpmc.com http://www.wwpmc.com