Japan's Great Wall: Can It Stop A Tsunami? | Foreign Correspondent
Nov, 2016 - "Five years on, cleanup of Fukushima's reactors remains a distant goal Removal of nuclear fuel from power plant that suffered triple meltdown following 2011 tsunami could take 40 years or more "
•Premiered 20 hours ago
TRANSCRIPT below
ABC News In-depth
When a massive tsunami engulfed the north-eastern coastline of Japan a decade ago, it wiped out everything in its path, flattening villages, killing nearly 20,000 people and triggering a nuclear meltdown.
The old seawalls which had been built along the coastline to protect villages and infrastructure offered little protection. Today, the government’s solution to a future tsunami is to build an even bigger and longer seawall to protect Japan’s coastal communities.
Up to 14 metres high and 400 kilometres long, the new seawall is dividing communities, and some fear, placing them in greater danger.
In this ARTE documentary, presented by former ABC Japan correspondent Mark Willacy, The Great Wall of Japan travels along the north-eastern coast of Japan’s main island to meet the fishermen and communities affected by one of the country’s biggest ever construction projects.
Oyster farmer Atsushi Fujita has mixed feelings about the wall, saying it’s destroying his community’s livelihood and culture.
“We're all very sad that our former lifestyle has gone and we can no longer see the ocean from our windows. It's really affecting us a lot.”
In the village of Akahama, fisherman Hiromi Kawaguchi has galvanised locals against the building of a giant wall. While he lost his wife and mother to the 2011 tsunami, he has no faith a new seawall will protect locals in the event of another great wave.
“In the last tsunami, the old wall was destroyed and its remains were left floating on the surface like cubes of tofu. Everything man-made is destined to be destroyed. It’s inevitable.”
But others support the wall, including construction executive Kazunori Yamamoto, who believes the old seawall saved his family in 2011.
“The breakwater earned us precious time, enabling a lot of people to escape. Without the breakwater, my whole family would have died.”
Scientists are divided on the benefits. Some say the wall will slow a tsunami’s advance, allowing more time for people to escape. Others say it will do the opposite, providing a false sense of security, delaying departure and putting people in greater danger.
Some believe the 13 billion US dollars spent on the wall’s construction could have been better used moving more communities to higher ground.
As Japan commemorates the tsunami’s 10th anniversary, this is a moving and timely story from the region hardest hit by the 2011 disaster.
About Foreign Correspondent: Foreign Correspondent is the prime-time international public affairs program on Australia's national broadcaster, ABC-TV. We produce half-hour duration in-depth reports for broadcast across the ABC's television channels and digital platforms. Since 1992, our teams have journeyed to more than 170 countries to report on war, natural calamity and social and political upheaval – through the eyes of the people at the heart of it all.
The original of that YouTube, with transcript here
The Great Wall of Japan
Posted Tue 2 Mar 2021, 8:00pm Updated Wed 3 Mar 2021, 11:33am Expires: Wednesday 28 January 4759 8:00pm
When a massive tsunami engulfed the north-eastern coastline of Japan a decade ago, it wiped out everything in its path, flattening villages, killing nearly 20,000 people and triggering a nuclear meltdown.
The old seawalls which had been built along the coastline to protect villages and infrastructure offered little protection.
Today, the government's solution to the next tsunami is to build an even bigger and longer seawall to protect Japan's coastal communities.
Up to 14 metres high and 400 kilometres long, the new seawall is dividing communities, and some fear, placing them in greater danger.
Presented by former Japan correspondent Mark Willacy, The Great Wall of Japan ravels along the north-eastern coast of Japan's main island to meet the fishermen and communities affected by one of the country's biggest ever construction projects.
Oyster farmer Atsushi Fujita has mixed feelings about the wall, saying it's destroying his community's livelihood and culture.
"We're all very sad that our former lifestyle has gone and we can no longer see the ocean from our windows. It's really affecting us a lot."
In the village of Akahama, fisherman Hiromi Kawaguchi has galvanised locals against the building of a giant wall. While he lost his wife and mother to the 2011 tsunami, he has no faith a new seawall will protect locals in the event of another great wave.
"In the last tsunami, the old wall was destroyed and its remains were left floating on the surface like cubes of tofu. Everything man-made is destined to be destroyed. It's inevitable."
But others support the wall, including construction executive Kazunori Yamamoto, who believes the old seawall saved his family in 2011.
"The breakwater earned us precious time, enabling a lot of people to escape. Without the breakwater, my whole family would have died."
cientists are divided on the benefits. Some say the wall will slow a tsunami's advance, allowing more time for people to escape. Others say it will do the opposite, providing a false sense of security, delaying departure and putting people in greater danger.
Some believe the $17 billion spent on the wall's construction could have been better used moving more communities to higher ground.
As Japan commemorates the tsunami's 10th anniversary, this is a moving and timely story from the region hardest hit by the 2011 disaster.
Transcript
MARK WILLACY, Reporter: A decade ago, a massive tsunami slammed into Japan, wiping out everything in its wake, killing thousands.
HIROMI KAWAGUCHI: "I was plunged into hell when I realised what happened to my home, my family and friends."
MARK WILLACY, Reporter: I was based in Japan as the ABC correspondent...
The Calm Before the Wave [...] Tsunamis strike somewhere in the world almost every year, and giant ones have arguably changed history. Some archaeologists have argued, for instance, that a Mediterranean tsunami struck the north shore of Crete a bit over 3,500 years ago; the disaster, they say, sent Minoan civilization, one of the most sophisticated of the age, into a tailspin, leading it to succumb to Mycenaean Greeks. In 1755, when an earthquake and tsunami killed tens of thousands in Lisbon, the tragedy had a lasting impact on Western thought: It helped demolish the complacent optimism of the day. In Voltaire's novel Candide the blinkered philosopher Pangloss arrives in Lisbon during the catastrophe, persists in arguing that "all is for the best in the best of all possible worlds," and gets hanged for his trouble. Voltaire's withering satire made it a little harder to be Panglossian—to believe that a benevolent God designed an optimal Earth. https://investorshub.advfn.com/boards/read_msg.aspx?message_id=72278288