Replies to post #1 on Bob Brinker Forum

[Math Junkie]

I'm willing to take a stab at moderating a board, but I'm not all that sure I want to go around "drumming up business."

[Kirk]

Will_L posted interesting data showing Brinker's BJ Group managed account matching the S&P500 since the peak of the bull market: http://www.suite101.com/discussion.cfm/investing/101527/1362-1371#message_2

Interesting that the performance is not at all like that advertised in the newsletter for model portfolio #1. Of course, those who participate in the "for a fee managed accounts" are not allowed "Mulligans" on QQQ investments.

What do you think? I find it very interesting that the portfolio actually under performend a PASSIVE benchmark portfolio between March 2000 and March 2004.