Replies to post #38 on America's Got Talent (show)

[gail]

hi skilz, I told the hubby tonight that we will hold off watching until you post your reviews.

we really get a kick out of seeing your comments first, then the act, then we post our thoughts... so, i have not read the reviews yet. I printed them up and will not look til we watch it tomorrow. ;-)

thx for doing what you do.

[gail]

ok, this time I will make my replies in red, and yours stay in black... bryan and I both are in on this reply to the show, as usual. he really gets a kick out of me printing up your thoughts.. and he listens intently. its kind of cute really.

My (your) Take on the show Last Night ..

1) Sal- The crooner, he was okay, but music drowned him out in parts, flat in others, he could of held on to some notes longer. Hit a few good notes along the way, not great, not bad.

Grade C

we liked him, he was ok... B

------------

2) Blake- The first magician, thought it was good. But I didn't like the invisibility trick when he was on the lift, his stage presence can use some work, and I have some idea how he pulled it off, which takes a bit away from it for me.

Grade B-

it was ok and entertaining.. B-

------------------

3) Edgar- I'm normally not a huge fan of these guys, not to say I dislike the family band, but I never was a believer like the judges. Yesterday however was the best we heard them overall, I thought it was pretty good, like the end, the song was good, for the most part the lead singer did a very good job, hitting some big notes along the way. Just liked it overall a lot more then I normally like their stuff.

Grade B+

rough start for her, harmony was off, and song was too slow... C

------------------

4) Lori- I Thought she was waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay better this week then last time. Finished extremely well, disagree with getting someone to write her material like one of the judges said I thought her material was fine last night. She has a good stage presence, although I could do without the laugh to start the act. I found her funny overall.

Grade B+

I liked her even less after she ripped on Trump and pushed Clinton in our face, and this time we both hated her act, even if we didnt know she was a lib. it was bad.. F

------------------

5) Musicality- I like them normally, but this was one of their weakest performances, I thought the solos were weak they could of picked a better song, they were actually better in the film they should of sang that song. Overall Slightly below average.

Grade C-

we hated it... D

-----------------

6) Deadly Games- They got away from their knives, which I liked. They had better stage presence, and I just thought the act was very good, and the increased production of the act was a plus. I really liked it.

Grade A-

it was very good, but similar acts, but yes, better production

-----------

7) Tape Face- He does more with less then I have ever seen and he is a character, having said that I thought the act was a bit silly, don't get me wrong overall I enjoyed this guy I just thought this wasn't his best, and quite frankly their are better acts that deserve to move on.

Grade C

we loved it... B+

--------------------

8) Jon Dorenbos- The football player turned magician, I thought his act was the best of the night up until this point, and one of the two best acts of the night overall. I like the tricks, waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay better stage presence then the other magic act, and I have no clue how he did it, which makes it even better.

Grade A

very good! A

----------------

9) Grace- She sang better in the second half of that song. Easier to understand then normal. Song wasn't terrible. Having said that just because I found this performance improved for her doesn't mean it was good overall. I don't love her style, a lot of times I still can't understand her., and a lot of times I don't love her songs, I know the judges love her, but I'm not as big of fan.

Grade C-

we thought it was oddly good. yes, the dialect is odd, but very good voice and quirky style... B

-----------------

10) Malevo- The dance group I thought they were very good, I like the addition of the water to the act, that upped the act in my opinion. I liked it.

Grade B+

we hated it. got bored, and the hubby said, as far as the water scene that you liked, it was like watching kids play in a puddle.... D

-------------

10) Laura- The little girl opera singer, now opera ain't my bag, but to be fair she is and amazing talent. I think one of the best two performances of the night in my opinion.

Grade A

it was very good but jackie evancho

was just sooooo much better, that we compare all of them, to her, in that case....

My Top 5
Laura
Deadly Games
Jon
(2 of the following three Malevo, Lori and Edgar) for me they are quite equal.

All is just my opinion, and I could always be wrong though.
you dont have to say that, as if you are talking about a stock on ihub, haha

who got kicked off? we were too busy to watch that one

good grief, look at our little jackie now! i just looked her up and she is all grown up.. and her new song plays, just let the site open... http://jackieevancho.com/