The emails you shared only prove that former controller Grushkin did indeed provide value to AAPT while serving as controller. This data has nothing to do with the obviously bogus allegations against Mr. Grushkin which accuse him of being misleading and being intentionally misleading. With in the realm of those 2 accusations you again prove nothing other than you have some type of sick obsession towards disparaging the one person that told the absolute truth about AAPT and in doing so, protected dogs from contaminated food products and unscrupulous managers intent on fleecing people such as you.
I recommend that you study business operations, business ethics, and U.S. securities and tax laws before boring us with additional irrelevant emails from the guy that may have kept your very own dog from being poisoned by an AAPT NutraBar.